“Bismarck fought 'necessary' wars and killed thousands, the idealists of the twentieth century fight 'just' wars and kill millions.”
Analysis
In this quote by historian A.J.P. Taylor, the distinction between necessary and just wars is highlighted. Bismarck, known for his realpolitik approach to diplomacy, waged wars that were deemed necessary for the unity and consolidation of Germany. In contrast, the idealists of the twentieth century, driven by moral or ideological motives, believed they were fighting just wars. However, Taylor points out that in their pursuit of justice, these idealists ended up causing more devastation and loss of life than the pragmatic leader Bismarck. This quote serves to challenge the notion that idealism always leads to more humanitarian outcomes in warfare.
Reflection Questions
Reflecting on the quote by A.J.P. Taylor, consider the differences between "necessary" wars and "just" wars. How do our modern ideals of morality and justice shape our perceptions of warfare? In what ways do the actions of historical figures like Bismarck shed light on the complexities of conflict and ethics? How can we navigate the tension between what is deemed necessary and what is deemed just in the context of war? Take some time to consider your own beliefs and values surrounding this topic, and how they may have been influenced by historical events and philosophical principles.
Modern Relevance of A.J.P. Taylor's quote
The quote by A.J.P. Taylor highlights the distinction between wars fought for necessity versus wars fought for justice. In today's world, the concept of just wars is often used to justify military interventions and conflicts. However, the consequences and casualties of these so-called "just" wars can sometimes lead to significant loss of life and destruction on a much larger scale than "necessary" wars. This raises important questions about the ethical considerations and the true justification of wars in the modern era.
War and its Justification
The quote by A.J.P. Taylor sheds light on the idea of war and the different justifications used throughout history.
“Bismarck fought 'necessary' wars and killed thousands, the idealists of the twentieth century fight 'just' wars and kill millions.” - A.J.P. Taylor
Similar quotes
“War means fighting, and fighting means killing.”
“It takes thousands of bullets to kill an army but one to end a war.”
“When you fight a war against a tyrant, who do you kill? You kill the victims of the tyrant.”
“The fact that in the twentieth century a greater proportion of the people in the world could communicate with one another, using English or just a few other languages, appears not to have stopped any wars, nor to have reduced the frequency with which wars have broken out, nor to have made the wars that have broken out less brutal. In fact, several murderous wars have been fought recently among people who speak 'the same language' in real terms.”
“I would rather make love than war, but only because condoms kill millions of lives more enjoyably.”