“I have said that there is no "average" American. That is due to the circumstance that the people of the United States differ from each as widely as the parts they live in. The New Yorker is a different specimen of man from the Westerner; the latter is entirely different again from the people of Texas. The Middle West, such States for instance as Kansas, Colorado, Nebraska or Iowa, have an entirely different psychology from that of Florida or Lower California. Their habits of life, their modes of thought, even their language is different. Still further, it must also be considered that millions of foreigners and descendants of foreign born people live in the United States and are part of the entire population that is known as "American". Add to this more than 10 million negroes, not to mention the score of different Indian (red-skin) tribes, who are the real, indigenous Americans. In this conglomeration of races it is impossible to speak of the "average" American, nor can any adequate estimate of American psychology be made on such a basis.”
Quote Analysis
In this quote by Alexander Berkman, he emphasizes the diversity of the American population, pointing out that there is no such thing as an "average" American due to the wide range of cultural, regional, and racial differences. Berkman highlights the distinct characteristics of various regions within the United States, as well as the presence of millions of immigrants, descendants of foreign-born individuals, African Americans, and indigenous tribes. This diversity makes it impossible to generalize or make assumptions about the American population as a whole.
Modern Relevance
In today's diverse and multicultural society, Alexander Berkman's observation about the wide range of backgrounds, perspectives, and experiences that make up the American population remains highly relevant. The United States continues to be a melting pot of various cultures, ethnicities, and beliefs, making it challenging to define a singular "average" American. This diversity enriches the country's social fabric but also requires a nuanced understanding of the different groups that contribute to the American identity.
Example of Usage
“I have said that there is no "average" American. That is due to the circumstance that the people of the United States differ from each as widely as the parts they live in. The New Yorker is a different specimen of man from the Westerner; the latter is entirely different again from the people of Texas. The Middle West, such States for instance as Kansas, Colorado, Nebraska or Iowa, have an entirely different psychology from that of Florida or Lower California. Their habits of life, their modes of thought, even their language is different. Still further, it must also be considered that millions of foreigners and descendants of foreign born people live in the United States and are part of the entire population that is known as "American". Add to this more than 10 million negroes, not to mention the score of different Indian (red-skin) tribes, who are the real, indigenous Americans. In this conglomeration of races it is impossible to speak of the "average" American, nor can any adequate estimate of American psychology be made on such a basis.” - Alexander Berkman"
Reflection Questions
This quote by Alexander Berkman highlights the diverse makeup of the American population and challenges the notion of an "average" American. Reflect on the following questions:
- How do you think the cultural, regional, and ethnic diversity in the United States contributes to the complexity of American identity?
- How has the presence of immigrants and their descendants shaped American society and culture?
- In what ways do you think differences in background and experiences among Americans can impact their perspectives on issues such as politics, social issues, and personal values?
- Reflect on your own identity and background. How have these factors influenced your understanding of what it means to be American?
Similar quotes
“The American press exists for one purpose only, and that is to convince Americans that they are living in the greatest and most envied country in the history of the world. The Press tells the American people how awful every other country is and how wonderful the United States is and how evil communism is and how happy they should be to have freedom to buy seven different sorts of detergent.”
“One of the least meaningful and most overused words in the English language is 'sustainability.' For most Americans, it means something like 'pretty much the way I live right now, though maybe with a different car.' A good test of any activity or product described as sustainable is to multiply it by 300 million (the approximate current population of the United States) and then by 9 or 10 billion (the expected population of the world by midcentury) and see if it still seems green. This is not an easy test to pass”
“Every American is from somewhere else. Each is hated for what he brings that is different from the rest. We live in uneasy peace. But it is peace, for the most part. ”
“It's very different because the Indians live as if they are their souls and Americans live as if they are their egos.”
“All the problems we face in the United States today can be traced to an unenlightened immigration policy on the part of the American Indian.”