“One new indulgence was to go out evenings alone. This I worked out carefully in my mind, as not only a right but a duty. Why should a woman be deprived of her only free time, the time allotted to recreation? Why must she be dependent on some man, and thus forced to please him if she wished to go anywhere at night?A stalwart man once sharply contested my claim to this freedom to go alone. “Any true man,” he said with fervor, “is always ready to go with a woman at night. He is her natural protector.” “Against what?” I inquired. As a matter of fact, the thing a woman is most afraid to meet on a dark street is her natural protector. Singular”
Quote Analysis:
In this quote by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, the speaker challenges societal norms regarding women's independence and freedom. The speaker questions why women should be dependent on men for companionship and protection, especially when it comes to something as simple as going out alone at night. The idea that a woman's "natural protector" may sometimes be the very thing she fears on a dark street is a powerful statement against traditional gender roles and expectations. Gilman's words advocate for women's autonomy and agency, highlighting the importance of individual freedom and self-reliance.
Modern Relevance
In this eloquent passage by Charlotte Perkins Gilman, the author challenges traditional gender roles and explores the concept of independence for women. The idea that women should not be dependent on men for their evening recreation time is still relevant today, as women continue to fight for equality and autonomy in all aspects of their lives. The discussion around women's safety and the assumption that men are always necessary as protectors also remains a topic of debate in contemporary society.
Reflecting on Women's Independence
Charlotte Perkins Gilman's words shed light on the societal expectations placed on women regarding their freedom to go out alone at night. In this passage, she challenges these norms and questions the notion of women needing a man as a protector.
"One new indulgence was to go out evenings alone. This I worked out carefully in my mind, as not only a right but a duty. Why should a woman be deprived of her only free time, the time allotted to recreation? Why must she be dependent on some man, and thus forced to please him if she wished to go anywhere at night? A stalwart man once sharply contested my claim to this freedom to go alone. 'Any true man,' he said with fervor, 'is always ready to go with a woman at night. He is her natural protector.' 'Against what?' I inquired. As a matter of fact, the thing a woman is most afraid to meet on a dark street is her natural protector. Singular."
Reflection Questions
In this excerpt from Charlotte Perkins Gilman, she explores the idea of women's independence and freedom to go out alone in the evenings. Reflect on the following questions:
- How does society's expectations of women's behavior and dependence on men influence women's ability to enjoy their free time and recreation alone?
- Do you agree with the idea that a woman should not have to rely on a man to accompany her when going out at night? Why or why not?
- Consider the notion of a man being a woman's natural protector. Do you believe this belief is still prevalent in today's society, and how does it affect women's autonomy and independence?
- Have you ever felt restricted or limited in your ability to go out alone in the evenings? How did this make you feel, and what actions did you take to assert your independence?
Similar quotes
“When a man finds this kind of woman, he will go all out for her knowing that she will not be a letdown.”
“Why? What kind of man would pleasure his woman by hurting her.' Angus paced across the path. ''Tis a man's duty, nay, his privilege, to give his woman all the pleasure she can bear. She should be panting and writhing with pleasure.'Emma remained silent, staring at him. Did she not believe him?He walked toward her. 'A real man would take all night if need be to make sure his woman was fully sated. She should be screaming that she canna endure any more.'Emma's eyes widened.'It should be a man's greatest pleasure to see his woman shuddering in the throes of passion.'She took a deep breath and shifted her weight from one foot to another.He paced back and forth. 'Only when she is begging for him should a man see to his own needs. And he should never, ever harm her.' He stopped in front of her 'Am I totally wrong in this?''No,' she squeaked.”
“Woman’s role in creation should be parallel to her role in life. I don’t mean the good earth. I mean the bad earth too, the demon, the instincts, the storms of nature. Tragedies, conflicts, mysteries are personal. Man fabricated a detachment which became fatal. Woman must not fabricate. She must descend into the real womb and expose its secrets and its labyrinths. She must describe it as the city of Fez, with its Arabian Nights gentleness, tranquility and mystery. She must describe the voracious moods, the desires, the worlds contained in each cell of it. For the womb has dreams. It is not as simple as the good earth. I believe at times that man created art out of fear of exploring woman. I believe woman stuttered about herself out of fear of what she had to say. She covered herself with taboos and veils. Man invented a woman to suit his needs. He disposed of her by identifying her with nature and then paraded his contemptuous domination of nature. But woman is not nature only.She is the mermaid with her fish-tail dipped in the unconscious.”
“And once I got old enough for such a thing to be a possibility, he told me that a man must be responsible for any seed he sows, for it's his duty to take care of a woman and protect her. And if I wasna prepared to do that, then I'd no right to burden a woman with the consequences of my own actions.”
“From the first day I met her, she was the only woman to me. Every day of that voyage I loved her more, and many a time since have I kneeled down in the darkness of the night watch and kissed the deck of that ship because I knew her dear feet had trod it. She was never engaged to me. She treated me as fairly as ever a woman treated a man. I have no complaint to make. It was all love on my side, and all good comradeship and friendship on hers. When we parted she was a free woman, but I could never again be a free man.”