“Since the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989, historians have become both more accurate and more honest—fractionally more brave, one might say—about that 'other' cleansing of the regions and peoples that were ground to atoms between the upper and nether millstones of Hitlerism and Stalinism. One of the most objective chroniclers is Professor Timothy Snyder of Yale University. In his view, it is still 'Operation Reinhardt,' or the planned destruction of Polish Jewry, that is to be considered as the centerpiece of what we commonly call the Holocaust, in which of the estimated 5.7 million Jewish dead, 'roughly three million were prewar Polish citizens.' We should not at all allow ourselves to forget the millions of non-Jewish citizens of Belarus, Russia, Ukraine, and other Slav territories who were also massacred. But for me the salient fact remains that anti-Semitism was the regnant, essential, organizing principle of all the other National Socialist race theories. It is thus not to be thought of as just one prejudice among many.”
Quote Analysis
In this quote by Christopher Hitchens, he discusses the importance of acknowledging and understanding the historical atrocities committed during the Holocaust, particularly focusing on the planned destruction of Polish Jewry known as 'Operation Reinhardt.' Hitchens emphasizes the central role of anti-Semitism in the Holocaust, highlighting how it was not just one prejudice among many but the essential organizing principle of all other National Socialist race theories. By citing Professor Timothy Snyder's research, Hitchens underscores the need for historians to be accurate and honest about the Holocaust and the millions of lives lost, including non-Jewish citizens of various Slav territories. This quote serves as a reminder of the horrors of the Holocaust and the significance of recognizing the role of anti-Semitism in this tragic chapter of history.
Modern Relevance:
In a world grappling with rising hate crimes and discrimination, Christopher Hitchens' words about the Holocaust and the centrality of anti-Semitism as the organizing principle behind it are more relevant than ever. Historians like Timothy Snyder continue to shed light on the atrocities committed during that dark period, emphasizing the need to remember and learn from the past to prevent such horrors from happening again.
Christopher Hitchens on the Holocaust and Anti-Semitism
"Since the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989, historians have become both more accurate and more honest—fractionally more brave, one might say—about that 'other' cleansing of the regions and peoples that were ground to atoms between the upper and nether millstones of Hitlerism and Stalinism. One of the most objective chroniclers is Professor Timothy Snyder of Yale University. In his view, it is still 'Operation Reinhardt,' or the planned destruction of Polish Jewry, that is to be considered as the centerpiece of what we commonly call the Holocaust, in which of the estimated 5.7 million Jewish dead, 'roughly three million were prewar Polish citizens.' We should not at all allow ourselves to forget the millions of non-Jewish citizens of Belarus, Russia, Ukraine, and other Slav territories who were also massacred. But for me the salient fact remains that anti-Semitism was the regnant, essential, organizing principle of all the other National Socialist race theories. It is thus not to be thought of as just one prejudice among many.” - Christopher Hitchens".
Reflection Questions
In the provided excerpt, Christopher Hitchens highlights the centrality of anti-Semitism in the Holocaust and emphasizes the significance of acknowledging the mass killings of not only Jewish individuals but also non-Jewish citizens in Slav territories under Hitlerism and Stalinism. In reflecting on this passage, consider the following questions:
- How does Hitchens' assertion that anti-Semitism was the organizing principle of National Socialist race theories shape your understanding of the Holocaust?
- In what ways do you think the recognition of the Operation Reinhardt's destruction of Polish Jewry as the centerpiece of the Holocaust impacts our collective memory and commemoration of this historical event?
- How can we ensure that the atrocities committed against non-Jewish citizens in Slav territories are not overshadowed or forgotten in discussions about the Holocaust?
- What actions can individuals take to combat anti-Semitism and prevent such ideologies from gaining traction in society today?
Similar quotes
“Scientists estimate that the Siberian permafrost holds the remains of 150 million mammoths—or about 8 million more than the 142 million Russians aboveground in Russia today.”
“The 20th century merits the name "The Century of Murder." 1915 Turks slaughtered 2 million Armenians. 1933 to 1954 the Soviet government encompassed the death of 20 to 65 million citizens. 1933 to 1945 Nazi Germany murdered more than 25 million people. 1948 Hindus and Muslims engaged in racial and religious strife that claimed more lives than could be reported. 1970 3 million Bangladesh were killed. 1971 Uganda managed the death of 300,000 people. 1975 Khmer Rouge took over Cambodia and murdered up to 3 million people. In recent times more than half a million of Rwanda's 6 million people have been murdered. At present times genocidal strife is underway in Bosnia, Somalia, Burundi and elsewhere. The people of the world have demonstrated themselves to be so capable of forgetting the murderous frenzies in which their fellows have participated that it is essential that one, at least, be remembered and the world be regularly reminded of it. _Consequences of the Holocaust by Raul Hilberg”
“The people in the world, and the objects in it, and the world as a whole, are not absolute things, but on the contrary, are the phenomena of perception... If we were all alike: if we were millions of people saying do, re, mi, in unison, One poet would be enough... But we are not alone, and everything needs expounding all the time because, as people live and die, each one perceiving life and death for himself, and mostly by and in himself, there develops a curiosity about the perceptions of others. This is what makes it possible to go on saying new things about old things.”
“Finally, from what we now know about the cosmos, to think that all this was created for just one species among the tens of millions of species who live on one planet circling one of a couple of hundred billion stars that are located in one galaxy among hundreds of billions of galaxies, all of which are in one universe among perhaps an infinite number of universes all nestled within a grand cosmic multiverse, is provincially insular and anthropocentrically blinkered. Which is more likely? That the universe was designed just for us, or that we see the universe as having been designed just for us?”
“There is little consolation in the fact that millions of people are unhappier than we are. Why should other people's misery make us happier or more content?”