“Thomas Hobbes's politics are fitted only to promote tyranny, and his ethics to encourage licentiousness.”
Reflection Questions
In light of David Hume's critique of Thomas Hobbes, what are your thoughts on the balance between political order and personal freedom? Do you believe that strict governmental control is necessary for societal stability, or do you lean more towards individual rights and autonomy?
How do you think a society influenced by Hobbes's political theory would differ from one influenced by his ethical principles? Can a government based on Hobbes's ideas of power and control also promote moral responsibility and ethical behavior among its citizens?
Do you agree with Hume's assertion that Hobbes's philosophy could lead to tyranny and licentiousness? How do you see these potential drawbacks playing out in a society that adheres strictly to Hobbes's teachings in politics and ethics?
Analysis
In this quote by David Hume, he critiques the political and ethical theories of Thomas Hobbes. Hume suggests that Hobbes's political ideas are conducive to tyranny, indicating that they prioritize centralized power and control over individual liberties. Additionally, Hume argues that Hobbes's ethical principles promote licentiousness, meaning a lack of moral restraint or self-discipline. Overall, this quote highlights Hume's skepticism towards Hobbes's views on governance and morality, suggesting a preference for a more balanced and nuanced approach to these concepts.
Thomas Hobbes and David Hume's Critiques
David Hume, a prominent figure in the Scottish Enlightenment, critiqued Thomas Hobbes for promoting tyranny and licentiousness through his politics and ethics. This criticism highlights the lasting relevance of their ideas to modern discussions on governance and ethics.
Critique of Thomas Hobbes by David Hume
"“Thomas Hobbes's politics are fitted only to promote tyranny, and his ethics to encourage licentiousness.” - David Hume"
Similar quotes
“For those of us who can't be active on the front lines - and this will be most of us - our job is to create a culture that will encourage and promote political resistance. The main tasks will be loyalty and material support.”
“one who, though he never digress to read a Lecture, Moral or Political, upon his own Text, nor enter into men’s hearts, further than the Actions themselves evidently guide him…filleth his Narrations with that choice of matter, and ordereth them with that Judgement, and with such perspicuity and efficacy expresseth himself that (as Plutarch saith) he maketh his Auditor a Spectator. For he setteth his Reader in the Assemblies of the People, and in their Senates, at their debating; in the Streets, at their Seditions; and in the Field, at their Battels.Quoted by Shelby Foote in his The Civil War: A Narrative – Volume 2: Fredericksburg to Meridian, Bibliographical Note, from Thomas Hobbes’ Forward to Hobbes’ translation of The Peloponnesian War by Thucydides”
“Political correctness is tyranny with manners.”
“Memory is a political act. Forgetfulness is the handmaiden of tyranny.”
“We believe that only government has the capacity--not to mention the political and moral responsibility--to promote the general welfare. Father Kramer as quoted in Sweet Charity?”