“You want to be French, Mary Frances, that's your problem, but instead you're just another American."I went to the window for that one an saw a marriage disintegrate before my eyes. Poor Mary Frances in her beige beret... "Americans," he repeated. "We don't live in in France, we live in Virginia. Vienna, Virginia. Got it?"I looked at this guy and knew for certain that if we'd met at a party he'd claim to live in Washington, D.C. Ask for a street address, and he'd look away, mumbling, "Well, just outside D.C.”
Modern Relevance
In this humorous anecdote by David Sedaris, the character's desire to be French and the conflict of being American is highlighted. The pressure to fit in with a certain cultural identity while also embracing your own heritage is a struggle many individuals face, particularly in today's globalized world. This excerpt serves as a reminder to embrace your own identity and not succumb to societal pressures or stereotypes.
Quote Analysis
In this quote, the speaker expresses a sense of disdain towards Mary Frances for aspiring to be French rather than embracing her American identity. The speaker implies that Mary Frances's desire to be French is a delusion, highlighting the contrast between her idealized image and reality. The speaker's frustration is palpable as he emphasizes the fact that they live in Virginia, not France, and attempts to ground Mary Frances in their actual surroundings. The imagery of Mary Frances in her beige beret symbolizes her misguided attempts to embody French culture, while the speaker's blunt insistence on their American reality underscores the disconnect between aspiration and truth. Additionally, the speaker's smug assertion that he lives just outside Washington, D.C. reveals a pretentiousness in his own identity and a desire to distance himself from typical American stereotypes. Overall, this quote explores themes of identity, cultural aspiration, and the clash between reality and perception.
Example of Usage:
"You want to be French, Mary Frances, that's your problem, but instead you're just another American."I went to the window for that one an saw a marriage disintegrate before my eyes. Poor Mary Frances in her beige beret... "Americans," he repeated. "We don't live in in France, we live in Virginia. Vienna, Virginia. Got it?"I looked at this guy and knew for certain that if we'd met at a party he'd claim to live in Washington, D.C. Ask for a street address, and he'd look away, mumbling, "Well, just outside D.C.” - David Sedaris"
Reflection Questions:
This passage by David Sedaris touches on themes of identity, cultural expectations, and the desire for a different life. As you reflect on this excerpt, consider the following questions:
- How does the character's desire to be French impact their sense of belonging and identity?
- In what ways do cultural expectations and stereotypes influence the characters' relationships and self-perception?
- How does the setting of Vienna, Virginia, versus Washington, D.C., reflect the characters' aspirations and realities?
- What do you think the author is trying to convey about the complexity of personal identity and the influence of societal norms in this passage?
Similar quotes
“Once you've lived in France, you don't want to live anywhere else, including France.”
“I don't live in France, I live in myself.”
“Hated France when I first got over here. Got on the train at Le Havre, and looked out of the window and thought it looked so exactly like America, I wanted to cry. The scenery flying past, the hills and barns and cows, were just the sort of things you keep coming across through a train window in the States. The Untrained Eye, I told myself, training it enough to see that all the signs were written in French, at the same time letting the untrained nose get its first exotic whiff of garlic from my traveling companions, and the untrained stomach its first attack of French dysentery. But still, these were the only differences. I asked myself finally what exactly did I expect France to look like? No answer.”
“The best of America drifts to Paris. The American in Paris is the best American. It is more fun for an intelligent person to live in an intelligent country. France has the only two things toward which we drift as we grow older—intelligence and good manners.”
“It was like one of those moments when people talked about their lives flashing before their eyes. Because as we stared at one another, every part of our relationship replayed in my mind's eye. I remembered how strong and invincible he'd been when we first met, when he'd come to bring Lissa and me back to the folds of Moroi society. I remembered the gentleness of his touch when he'd bandaged my bloodied and battered hands. I remembered him carrying me in his arms after Victor's daughter Natalie had attacked me. Most of all, I remembered the night we'd been together in the cabin, just before the Strigoi had taken him. A year. We'd known each other only a year, but we'd lived a lifetime in it.”