“But how,” said Charles, who was close to tears, “how can you possibly justify cold-blooded murder?’ Henry lit a cigarette. “I prefer to think of it,” he had said, “as redistribution of matter.”
Analysis of Quote from Donna Tartt
In this quote from Donna Tartt, the character Henry justifies cold-blooded murder by referring to it as "redistribution of matter." This statement is both thought-provoking and chilling, as it challenges traditional moral boundaries and highlights the character's disturbing perspective on violence and death. This quote raises questions about the nature of morality and the ethics surrounding violent acts, forcing readers to consider the implications of such a rationalization.
Exploring the philosophical justification for violence
In this quote from Donna Tartt's novel, two characters discuss the concept of murder and its justification. Henry's response, framing murder as a "redistribution of matter," challenges traditional views on violence and morality. This discussion prompts us to consider the modern relevance of this perspective in a society where ethical justifications for violence are constantly debated.
Example of Usage:
In this dialogue excerpt from Donna Tartt's novel, "The Secret History," the character Henry justifies murder in a chilling manner. Charles questions the morality of cold-blooded murder, to which Henry responds with a seemingly callous perspective.
Reflection Questions:
As we think about this chilling justification for murder presented in the quote, it's important to reflect on our own beliefs and values. Consider the following questions:
- How do you define morality and ethical behavior? Do you believe there are circumstances where cold-blooded murder can be justified?
- What role do personal beliefs and values play in our perceptions of right and wrong?
- How do you reconcile the idea of "redistribution of matter" with the inherent value of human life?
- In what ways can the characters' perspectives in this quote challenge or reinforce our own moral compasses?
Similar quotes
“If it's healed, then why does it still hurt?" I said, panicked.What if the pain never went away? How was I supposed to live with that? Had Henry experienced the same thing in his chest? How could he have possibly fought of that thing again if he had?"Because there is no power in the world that can take away the pain until it is ready to leave." said Theo”
“The guy's name was Colt.Colt, said Thebes. Like a baby, male horse?I guess, said the guy, or a gun.Well, which do you prefer? she said.What do you mean? he asked.Like, how do you prefer to think of yourself? As a baby, male horse?No, he said, he didn't really like to think of himself that way.Well, then, as a gun? she said.No, not really, he said. He preferred basically not to think of himself at all.”
“You said 'God is cruel' the way a person who's lived his whole life on Tahiti might say 'Snow is cold'. You knew, but you didn't understand." He stepped close to David and put his palms on the boy's cold cheeks. "Do you know how cruel your God can be, David. How fantastically cruel?”
“When I first met him, he had a recurrent nightmare that Henry Kissinger was chasing him with a knife, and I said it was really his father, and he said it was really Henry Kissinger, and I said it was his father and he said it was Henry Kissinger, and this went on for months until he started going to the Central American shrinkette, who said Henry Kissinger was really his younger sister.”
“The head of the sledgehammer was cold, icy cold, and it touched his forehead as gently as a kiss. 'Pock! There,' said Czernobog. 'Is done.' There was a smile on his face that Shadow had never seen before, an easy, comfortable smile, like sunshine on a summer's day. The old man walked over to the case, and he put the hammer away, and closed the bag, and pushed it back under the sideboard. 'Czernobog?' asked Shadow. Then, 'Are you Czernobog?''Yes. For today,' said the old man. 'By tomorrow, it will all be Bielebog. But today, is still Czernobog.' 'Then why? Why didn't you kill me when you could?'The old man took out an unfiltered cigarette from a pack in his pocket. He took a large box of matches from the mantelpiece and lit the cigarette with a match. He seemed deep in thought. 'Because,' said the old man, after some time, 'there is blood. But there is also gratitude. And it has been a long, long winter.”