“Why can't poets just say what they want to say and then shut up?”
Explore This Quote Further
Gary D. Schmidt on Poets Speaking Out
"Why can't poets just say what they want to say and then shut up?" - Gary D. Schmidt
This quote by Gary D. Schmidt reflects a common frustration with poets who may use excessive words or metaphors to convey their message. Schmidt's statement raises questions about the effectiveness of poetic language and whether it can sometimes obscure rather than illuminate meaning.
Analysis
In this quote by Gary D. Schmidt, the frustration with poets who don't communicate their thoughts directly is evident. The quote suggests that poets often use complex and convoluted language to express their ideas, making it difficult for the audience to fully grasp their message. Schmidt seems to advocate for a more straightforward and concise approach to communication, questioning the need for poets to be so enigmatic in their expression. This quote highlights the ongoing debate between the beauty of poetic language and the clarity of straightforward communication.
Modern Relevance
In today's fast-paced world of social media and instant communication, the idea of concise and direct communication is more important than ever. With attention spans getting shorter and shorter, people often appreciate when writers and poets get straight to the point without unnecessary embellishments. This quote by Gary D. Schmidt highlights the importance of brevity and clarity in communication, a lesson that is still relevant in today's digital age.
Reflection Questions
Gary D. Schmidt's question raises an interesting point about the nature of poetry. Reflecting on this statement can lead us to consider the purpose of poetry, the power of language, and the importance of interpretation. Here are some questions to ponder:
Why do you think poets choose to communicate their thoughts and emotions through poetry instead of more straightforward forms of writing?
How does the ambiguity and imagery in poetry contribute to its impact on the reader?
Do you believe that the reader's interpretation of a poem is just as valid as the poet's intended meaning? Why or why not?
In what ways can the act of reading and interpreting poetry enhance our understanding of ourselves and the world around us?
How does the brevity and conciseness of poetry allow for deeper reflection and connection with the reader?
Similar quotes
“You know, there are good reasons to learn how to read. Poetry isn't one of them. I mean, so what if two roads go two ways in a wood? So what? Who cares if it made all that big a difference? What difference? And why should I have to guess what the difference is? Isn't that what he's supposed to say?Why can't poets just say what they want to say and then shut up?”
“You can't just skip the boring parts.""Of course I can skip the boring parts.""How do you know they're boring if you don't read them?""I can tell.""Then you can't say you've read the whole play.""I think I can live a happy life, Meryl Lee, even if I don't read the boring parts of The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark.""Who knows?" she said. "Maybe you can't.”
“I love the sound of a brand-new bottle of coke when you pry the lid off and it starts to fizz. Whenever I hear that sound, I think of roses, and of sitting together with someone you care about and of Romeo and Juliet waking up somewhere and saying to each other, weren't we jerks? And then having all that be over. That's what I think of when I hear the sound of a brand-new bottle of Coke being opened”
“Do you ever wonder what it's like to be so angry that you...And then something happens, and after that, everyone figures that's what you're like, and that's what you're always going to be, and so you just decide to be it? But the whole time you're thinking, Am I going to be like him? Or am I already like him? And then you get angrier, because maybe you are, and you want...He stopped. He wiped at his eyes. I'm not lying. My brother wiped at his eyes.”
“I saw my town as if I had just arrived. It was as if I was waking up. You see houses and buildings every day, and you walk by them on your way to something else, and you hardly see. You hardly notice they're even there, mostly because there's something else going on right in front of your face, But when the town itself becomes the thing that is going on right in front of your face, it all changes, and you're not just looking at a house, but at what's happened in that house before you were born.”
“I never knew a building could hold so much inside.. . . I saw my town as if I had just arrived. It was as if I was waking up. You see houses and buildings every day, and you walk by them on your way to something else, and you hardly see. You hardly notice they're even there, mostly because there's something else going on right in front of your face. But when the town itself becomes the thing that is going on right in front of your face, it all changes, and you're not just looking at a house but at what's happened in that house before you were born.”