“This reminded him of Alvis Bender's contention that stories were like nations - Italy, a great epic poem, Britain, a thick novel, America, a brash motion picture in technicolor...”
Quote Analysis
In this quote from Jess Walter's novel, the comparison of stories to nations provides a unique perspective on the different styles and formats of storytelling. By likening Italy to a great epic poem, Britain to a thick novel, and America to a brash motion picture in technicolor, the quote highlights the diverse approaches to storytelling and the cultural nuances that shape these narratives. Just as nations have their own unique characteristics and histories, so too do stories reflect the nuances of their origins and creators. This comparison underscores the rich tapestry of storytelling traditions that exist across different cultures and literary forms, illustrating the endless possibilities for creativity and imagination in the world of storytelling.
Exploring the Modern Relevance of Alvis Bender's Analogy
In Jess Walter's quote, Alvis Bender compares stories to nations, with each country representing a different genre of storytelling. This analogy can be seen as a way to understand the diversity and impact of storytelling in today's world. Just as different nations have unique cultural identities, storytelling channels such as books, films, and epic poems offer varied perspectives and experiences that shape our understanding of the world. In the digital age, where storytelling is constantly evolving through new mediums and platforms, Bender's comparison reminds us of the power and significance of narratives in shaping our collective consciousness.
Comparing Stories to Nations
"This reminded him of Alvis Bender's contention that stories were like nations - Italy, a great epic poem, Britain, a thick novel, America, a brash motion picture in technicolor..." - Jess Walter
Reflection Questions
As we think about stories being compared to nations in different forms of art, what do you believe this analogy reveals about the essence of storytelling? How does each of the examples given - Italy as a great epic poem, Britain as a thick novel, America as a brash motion picture in technicolor - resonate with you personally? In what ways do you see this comparison influencing your own understanding and appreciation of various genres of storytelling?
Similar quotes
“America wielded her huge power in the world with a brash confidence that reminded him of a toddler who has got hold of a hammer.”
“In America they have to know just what you are-- novelist, poet, playwright... Well, I've been all of them... I think poems and novels and stories spring from the same seed. It's not like, say, playing polo and knitting.”
“A legacy that powerful does not disappear. Next to the Egyptians, the Greeks and Romans were babies. Our modern nations like Great Britain and America? Blinks of an eye...The very oldest root of civilization, at least of Western civilization, is Egypt. Look at the pyramid on the dollar bill. Look at the Washington Monument—the world’s largest Egyptian obelisk. Egypt is still.......very much alive.”
“America: It's like Britain, only with buttons.”
“The right, indeed, is indestructible. Warsaw can no more be Tartar than Venice can be Teutonic. Kings waste their energies in that contention, and lose their honour. Sooner or later the submerged nation rises again to the surface; Greece is still Greece and Italy, Italy... The theft of a people can never be justified. These august swindles have no future. A nation cannot be shaped as though it were a pocket handkerchief.”