“The first symptom of the trouble appeared when Madison studied Hamilton’s proposal for the funding of the domestic debt. On the one hand, Hamilton’s recommendation looked straightforward: All citizens who owned government securities should be reimbursed at par—that is, the full value of the government’s original promise. But many original holders of the securities, mainly veterans of the American Revolution who had received them as pay for their service in the war, had then sold them at a fraction of their original value to speculators. What’s more, the release of Hamilton’s plan produced...”
Explore This Quote Further
Analysis of Quote by Joseph J. Ellis
In this quote by Joseph J. Ellis, he discusses the conflict between James Madison and Alexander Hamilton over the funding of the domestic debt. Hamilton's proposal to reimburse all citizens who owned government securities at their original value created tension as many original holders had sold them at a fraction of their value to speculators. This situation highlights the complexities and conflicts that arose in early American politics, as different perspectives and interests clashed over economic policies.
Modern Relevance:
In Joseph J. Ellis's analysis of the early American government's struggles with debt and financial policy, we can draw parallels to modern debates surrounding economic justice and wealth inequality. Hamilton's proposal to reimburse government securities at par value, despite the speculators having purchased them at a fraction of their original worth, raises questions about fairness and the role of government in regulating financial markets. Today, issues of wealth consolidation and the impact of economic policies on different socio-economic groups continue to be significant topics of discussion.
Analysis of Hamilton's Proposal by Madison
"The first symptom of the trouble appeared when Madison studied Hamilton’s proposal for the funding of the domestic debt. On the one hand, Hamilton’s recommendation looked straightforward: All citizens who owned government securities should be reimbursed at par—that is, the full value of the government’s original promise. But many original holders of the securities, mainly veterans of the American Revolution who had received them as pay for their service in the war, had then sold them at a fraction of their original value to speculators. What’s more, the release of Hamilton’s plan produced..." - Joseph J. Ellis
Reflection Questions:
As we consider the situation between Madison and Hamilton regarding the funding of the domestic debt, it raises some important questions for reflection:
How should a government balance the interests of original holders of securities with those of speculators who purchased them at a discounted rate?
What ethical considerations come into play when deciding how to reimburse individuals for their government securities?
In what ways do economic policies, such as Hamilton's funding proposal, impact different segments of society, such as veterans of the American Revolution and speculators?
How can conflicts such as this one between Madison and Hamilton be resolved in a way that is fair and just for all parties involved?
Similar quotes
“For Madison, on the other hand, “a Public Debt is a Public curse,” and “in a Representative Government greater than in any other.”26”
“But if insecurity was the primal source of Hamilton's incredibly energy, one would have to conclude that providence had conspired to produce at the most opportune moment perhaps the most creative liability in American history.”
“Jefferson appeared to his enemies as an American version of Candide; Hamilton as an American Machiavelli.”
“James Jackson actually made menacing faces at the Quakers in the gallery, calling them outright lunatics, then launched into a tirade so emotional and incoherent that reporters in the audience had difficulty recording his words.”
“One of the petitioners, an infamous do-gooder of uncertain sanity named Warner Mifflin, had actually acknowledged that his antislavery vision came to him after he was struck by lightning in a thunderstorm.”
“Burr had the dark and severe coloring of his Edwards ancestry, with black hair receding from the forehead and dark brown, almost black, eyes that suggested a cross between an eagle and a raven. Hamilton had a light peaches and cream complexion with violet-blue eyes and auburn-red hair, all of which came together to suggest an animated beam of light to Burr’s somewhat stationary shadow.”