“You seem to be under the impression that there is a special breed of bad humans. There is no such thing as a stereotype bad man in this world. Under normal conditions, everybody is more or less good, or, at least, ordinary. But tempt them, and they may suddenly change. That is what is so frightening about men.”
Explore This Quote Further
-
Working on it...
-
Working on it...
Quote Analysis: Natsume Soseki on Human Nature
This quote by Natsume Soseki explores the complexity and duality of human nature. It challenges the common belief that evil is confined to a distinct group of inherently "bad" people, instead suggesting that morality is fluid and context-dependent.
Soseki begins by rejecting the idea of a "special breed" of bad humans, emphasizing that most people are generally good or at least ordinary under normal circumstances. This implies that evil or wrongdoing is not an innate trait fixed in a few, but a potential within everyone.
The turning point in the quote is the notion of temptation as a catalyst for change. When people face challenging or provocative situations, their behavior can dramatically shift, revealing darker sides. This unpredictability is what Soseki identifies as frightening—the idea that anyone can "suddenly change" based on external conditions.
Ultimately, the quote encourages readers to reconsider simplistic categories of "good" and "bad," highlighting the fragile and situational nature of human morality. It serves as a cautionary reflection on the latent potential for change in every individual.
Reflection Questions on Natsume Soseki's Quote
Natsume Soseki’s insight challenges us to reconsider our perceptions of human nature and morality. Reflecting on these questions can deepen your understanding of the complexities within people and the forces that influence behavior.
- What does Soseki suggest about the nature of good and evil in people?
- How do you interpret the idea that "under normal conditions, everybody is more or less good, or, at least, ordinary"?
- In what ways do external circumstances or "temptations" influence a person's behavior?
- Can you think of examples from your own experience or history where someone changed drastically due to pressure or temptation?
- How does this perspective challenge common stereotypes about "bad" people?
- What implications does this view have for forgiveness and judgment?
- How might understanding this idea affect the way we treat others in difficult situations?
- Do you believe there are truly "bad" people, or are actions always a product of circumstance and choice? Why?
- How can society create conditions that minimize the temptations or pressures that cause people to act out of character?
Similar quotes
“On the whole, all people are good, or at least they're normal. The frightening thing is that they can suddenly turn bad when it comes to the crunch.”
“Now that I thought about it, though, I realized that most people actually encourage you to turn bad. They seem to think that if you don't, you'll never get anywhere in the world. And then on those rare occasions when they encounter somebody who's honest and pure-hearted, they look down on him and say he's nothing but a kid, a Botchan. If that's the way it is, it would be better if they didn't have those ethics classes in elementary school and middle school where the teacher is always telling you to be honest and not lie. The schools might as well just go ahead and teach you how to tell lies, how to mistrust everybody, and how to take advantage of people. Wouldn't their students, and the world at large, be better off that way? Redshirt had laughed at me for being simpleminded. If people are going to get laughed at for being simpleminded and sincere, there's no hope. Kiyo never laughed at me for saying anything like what I said to Redshirt. She would have been deeply impressed by it. Compared to Redshirt, she's far and away the superior person.”
“He saw the human shadows flitting through his second world. Most of them had unkempt beards. Some walked along looking at the sky, others at the ground. All wore shabby clothing. All lived in poverty. And all were serene. Closed in on every side by streetcars, they freely breathed the air of peace. The men in this world were unfortunate, for they knew nothing of the real world. But they were fortunate as well, for they had fled the Burning House of worldly suffering. Professor Hirota was in this second world. So, too, was Nonomiya. Sanshiro stood where he could understand the air of this world more or less. He could leave it whenever he wished. But to do so, to relinquish a taste he had finally begun to savor, was something he was loath to do.”
“Living as I do with human beings, the more that I observe them, the more I am forced to conclude that they are selfish.”
“I am a lonely man,' Sensei said. 'And so I am glad that you come to see me. But I am also a melancholy man, and so I asked you why you should wish to visit me so often.”
“I would guess that he thought and thought for at least ten years before he came up with a stupendous idea, that glory of man's inventiveness, pants.”