“We are never prepared for so many to die. So you understand? No one is. We expect some chosen few. We expect an occasional empty chair, a toast to dear departed comrades. Victory celebrations for most of us, a hallowed death for a few. But the war goes on. And men die. The price gets ever higher. Some officers can pay no longer. We are prepared to lose some of us, but never all of us. But that is the trap. You can hold nothing back when you attack. You must commit yourself totally. And yet, if they all die, a man must ask himself, will it have been worth it?”
Quote Analysis
In this quote from Michael Shaara's novel, the speaker is grappling with the difficult reality of war and its devastating consequences. The speaker acknowledges that no one can ever truly be prepared for the massive loss of life that comes with warfare. While some deaths may be expected, the sheer number of casualties can be overwhelming. The speaker reflects on the idea that in order to be successful in war, one must fully commit and not hold anything back. However, this very commitment can lead to the tragic possibility of losing all those involved in the conflict. The quote raises poignant questions about the true cost of war and whether the sacrifices made are truly worth it in the end.
Modern Relevance:
During times of conflict and war, the poignant words of Michael Shaara continue to hold significance in the modern world. The emotional and ethical dilemmas faced by soldiers and leaders alike are still relevant today, as the costs of war continue to escalate. In a world where the sacrifices of many are often overshadowed by the demands of society, Shaara's words serve as a reminder of the profound impact of war on individuals and communities.
Example of Usage
In this quote from Michael Shaara's novel, the characters confront the harsh reality of war and the toll it takes on those involved. The idea of losing all comrades in battle and questioning the worth of sacrifice is a difficult and poignant reflection on the nature of conflict.
Reflection Questions
In Michael Shaara's powerful words, we are confronted with the harsh reality of war and the toll it takes on those involved. It forces us to consider the value of sacrifice and the cost of victory. Reflecting on this passage, here are some questions to ponder:
- How do you define a "hallowed death" in the context of war? Do you believe there is such a thing, or is all death in combat equally tragic?
- Shaara suggests that in war, one must commit oneself totally. Do you agree with this sentiment, or do you believe that there are limits to the sacrifices one should make?
- Consider the idea of "holding nothing back when you attack." In your own life, have you ever had to commit yourself completely to a cause or goal? What was the outcome, and was it worth it?
- The passage raises the question of whether the ultimate sacrifice of losing all men in battle can ever be justified. How would you answer this question? Are there situations in which the cost of victory is simply too high?
Similar quotes
“They rode for a while in silence, a tiny island in the smoky stream of marching men. Then Lee said slowly, in a strange, soft, slow tone of voice, "Soldiering has one great trap." Longstreet turned to see his face. Lee was riding slowly ahead, without expression. He spoke in that same slow voice. "To be a good soldier you must love the army. But to be a good officer you must be willing to order the death of the thing you love. This is...a very hard thing to do. No other profession requires it. That is one reason why there are so very few good officers. Although there are many good men." Lee rarely lectured. Longstreet sensed a message beyond it. He waited. Lee said, "We don't fear our own deaths, you and I." He smiled slightly, then glanced away. "We protect ourselves out of military necessity, not do not protect yourself enough and must give thought to it. I need you. But the point is, we are afraid to die. We are prepared for our own deaths, and for the deaths of comrades. We learn that at the Point. But I have seen this happen: we are not prepared for as many deaths as we have to face, inevitably as the war goes on. There comes a time..." He paused. He had been gazing straight ahead, away from Longstreet. Now, black-eyed, he turned back, glanced once quickly into Longstreet's eyes, then looked away. "We are never prepared for so many to die. So you understand? No one is. We expect some chosen few. We expect an occasional empty chair, a toast to dear departed comrades. Victory celebrations for most of us, a hallowed death for a few. But the war goes on. And the men die. The price gets ever higher. Some officers...can pay no longer. We are prepared to lose some of us." He paused again. "But never ALL of us. Surely not all of us. But...that is the trap. You can hold nothing back when you attack. You must commit yourself totally. And yet ,if they all die, a man must ask himself, will it have been worth it?”
“I realize that sometimes death comes before you expect it. That while we are rarely prepared for our friends, family and loved ones to die, we are never prepared for our own deaths. Never prepared to reconcile our own regrets.”
“True. The one certainty about riding, Braygan, is that - at some time - you will fall off. It is a fact. Another fact you might like to consider, in your life of perpetual terror, is that you will die. We are all going to die, some of us young, some of us old, some of us in our sleep, some of us screaming in agony. We cannot stop it, we can only delay it.”
“We are born, we suffer, we die. However, love is a possibility for us all and, for some few, there is also a big house."Daniel could not resist asking, because he really wanted to know. "Need they be mutually exclusive? Can't we have both love and house?"Joe smiled. "Certainly. But one must consider carefully how one goes about getting the house.”
“Death is not defeat, Tool told himself. We all die. Every one of us. Rip and Blade and Fear and all the rest. We all die. So what if you are the last? You were designed to be destroyed.”